Taiwan: The President Pans Google, Yahoo on Free Speech
In a speech commemorating a local human rights activist, Taiwan President Chen Shui-bian accused Yahoo Inc. and Google Inc. of allowing the prospect of corporate profits to lure them into compromising free speech in China.
"I again call on China's Communist government and on multinationals that
have sacrificed freedom of speech for corporate profits, including well known
companies such as Yahoo and Google, to respect democracy and freedom, because
it is the correct way to ensure continuous future development," Chen
said in the speech Friday.
Taiwan's president used the 17th annual commemorative ceremony for human rights
activist Cheng Nan-jung as a platform for his speech, arguing that countries
should not compromise free speech or freedom of the press for any reason.
Cheng, former publisher of a weekly magazine dedicated to protesting government
suppression of press freedoms in Taiwan, set himself on fire in 1989 during
an attempt by police to arrest him.
Since the incident, Taiwan has developed one of the most vibrant democracies
in Asia, with full press and speech freedoms. The island enjoyed its third
free presidential election in 2004, with the incumbent, Chen, winning his
second term in office.
Neither Google nor Yahoo immediately answered a request for comment about
the speech.
Google launched a censored version of its search engine in China in January.
It argued that it was better if it offered users there a compromised version
of its search service rather than none at all. The company came under fire
in the U.S. and elsewhere for the move.
Censors and strong firewalls in China slow the performance of overseas Internet
sites. Only by locating servers in China can a company such as Google speed
up its site, but putting servers in the country also gives Beijing control
over how the company runs its business.
Yahoo has faced criticism for turning e-mails over to Chinese police that
put a journalist in jail for 10-years.
China has long held the hope that someday Taiwan might become part of its
territory despite wide political differences. China is controlled by the Communist
Party, and its citizens enjoy few personal freedoms. Taiwan's constitution
is modeled after that of the U.S., which grants far-reaching rights to citizens.
China has offered to allow Taiwan to continue to operate under its own political
system if it would become part of China. Taiwan has cited its various political
freedoms, and the lack thereof in China, as its main reason for refusing to
be part of such an arrangement. China and Taiwan split in 1949 after a civil
war. Since then, China has maintained a threat to attack the island if it
declares independence.